Pages

Showing posts with label movie better. Show all posts
Showing posts with label movie better. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

Teen Tuesdays - Angus, Thongs and Perfect Snogging THE MOVIE (2008) (Directed by Gurinder Chadha)

Angus Thongs & Perfect Snogging

I've just finished watching the movie Angus, Thongs and Perfect Snogging. It is based on the Confessions of Georgia Nicolson teen novel series. Being a teen movie, I did not have very high expectations for this film. I found the books to be entertaining, and laugh-out-loud funny at times, but the online ratings for this film were not very high.

The movie gets off to a great start, with Georgia walking down the street in her stuffed olive costume while her dad trails her in his car. When she gets to the party she is going to, she is disappointed to see her "ace gang" (friends) did not go with their theme of hors d'oeuvres, and are instead wearing typical "cute/sexy" costumes girls usually wear to costume parties (an angel, devil, and princess).  She is laughed at by the party-goers, and is told by her best friend basically that boys don't like funny girls. This is your first taste of Georgia, and immediately, the viewer can see how different Georgia really is.

Over the next couple of scenes, you're introduced to the rest of the characters, and how they translate on-screen. I think the casting was marvelous in this film. The actors weren't actors I was familiar with, which made it a lot easier to picture them as the characters in the book. The actors really did portray the characters exactly as they were in the novels, and being a fan of the books, this made me pretty happy.

The movie was full of colour, and snappy (mostly British) pop songs that really fit the mood. It was your typical teen movie with plenty of drama and gushing over the opposite sex. As much as I would like to say I hated it, I was captivated and it did make me smile. ...At least for the first half.

The first half of the the movie did not stray too far from what happened in the books. I believe the story line took us through the first book with a few elements from the second book wedged in to keep the plot going. The conversations between the characters often mimicked the conversations read in the book, they used the same slang, and they even said some things in French as Georgia and the ace gang often did in the written series. The Disco Inferno dancing, kissing lessons, and name of the band, The Stiff Dylans, held true to the novels, and I really appreciate that when watching a film based on a book.

Other than the "Sex Gods" being twins (they are just brothers in the book), the boys going to the same school (Georgia goes to an all-girls' school in the book), and the "Sex God" having a cat (no mention of this in the book), the beginning of the movie held pretty true to the book.

HOWEVER...

Then you reach the second half of the movie where everything goes awry. I don't know if it's just me, but nothing was as I remembered it in the books. The second half of the film seems to be more about Georgia trying to keep her parents from divorcing than anything else. She even goes to the extent of talking to her dad's boss to try to get him to transfer her dad back from New Zealand and agreeing to move there in order to keep her parents from splitting up.

The movie suddenly goes into true "teen-movie" mode when all of a sudden this modest-looking family has the big bucks to throw Georgia a "Hollywood" style birthday party at a club. Out of nowhere, the unpopular and awkward Georgia has the whole school at her party while the pretty and popular Lindsay sits alone. Lindsay, obviously being portrayed as the villain, then tries to ruin Georgia's party by putting Georgia down in front of everyone on stage. Of course we had to have a happy ending though, so Robbie (The Sex God) rejects Lindsay and goes in for a big, public, kiss with Georgia.

This film had potential to be quite a good comparison with the books, but I think it failed miserably towards the end. Great if you're just looking for a teen movie to entertain you, awful if you're looking for it to follow the story-line in the books. I hope they aren't planning on a sequel, because I think it would just sorely disappoint anyone who became a fan of the written series.

Sunday, July 11, 2010

Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane - THE BOOK

Shutter Island (1st)

I've just finished reading Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane. I'll admit this was not one of my typical choices of books. I'm not really into the dark, mystery genre, but after seeing the trailers for the film, and finding out that it was originally a book, I really wanted to read it first before seeing the movie.

I read several reviews online saying the book was way better than the movie. Well, without seeing the movie, I'd have to say the movie has a lot to live up to. 

I've never read anything by Lehane before, but I have to say I throughly enjoyed his writing. He has a wonderful way of describing every detail that makes you really be able to picture being there. The book makes numerous references to water, and as you read them, you can feel the dampness he is describing. 

This book was quite an easy read, easy to get into, and difficult to put down. I read it over 3 days, mostly due to threats from my fiancĂ© that he wanted to rent the movie next week, but also because the plot was so good it just left you craving more. 

Several twists in the plot created just the right amount of suspense to keep you reading. I suspected at the beginning of the book that the main character, Teddy, could be a patient at the facility on the island, but the way that Lehane put it all together was quite genius. 

All in all, the book left quite a good taste in my mouth for Dennis Lehane's writing, and I'm very interested to read some of his other books. I can see how they could make a great movie out of this book, but worry that it may fall flat.

Welcome!

So I've decided to write a blog.... So you're wondering, what have I got to offer you? Well, after countless times of begging my fiancĂ© to wait to see a movie "until I've read the book", I've decided to share my opinion of which is truly better The Book, Or, The Movie. 

In this blog I hope to strike up conversation, and share my opinion as to whether or not the story is captured better in the book, or in Hollywoods adaptation of it. So far, personally, I think the books have got it stacked. 

I invite you to comment on any of my posts and share your opinion as well since my interpretations may differ from your own. I also warn you in advance that my entries may include some spoilers. 

So for all of you literary buffs and movie buffs alike, let's finally find an answer to this "chicken or the egg" argument, and discover which one is better, THE BOOK, OR, THE MOVIE.